If you’re a solo user on Windows looking for a modern, user-friendly file management experience, choose Files. Its WinUI 3 interface, dual panes, and tagging system significantly enhance usability compared to the standard File Explorer. However, if you need cross-platform compatibility or advanced features like scripting or FTP, you should skip this option.
On the other hand, if your focus is on managing photos and videos with privacy in mind, consider immich. It's perfect for tech-savvy users who can handle the self-hosting setup and seek high performance in their media management. But this is not the right choice if you prefer a straightforward cloud solution or need extensive integrations with other services.