If you prioritize complete control over your photo and video collection and have the technical skills to handle self-hosting, go with immich. It's an excellent choice for those who value privacy and seek a high-performance management solution without the limitations of cloud services. This option is not suitable if you prefer a hassle-free, cloud-based system or require extensive third-party integrations.
On the other hand, if you're a Mac user looking for a powerful tool to enhance your workflow through automation, Alfred is the way to go. Its mature design offers speed and efficiency, especially with the paid Powerpack features. However, steer clear if you need cross-platform support or built-in AI functionalities, as Alfred is limited to Mac. Choose immich for privacy and control; opt for Alfred for Mac-centric automation and productivity.